Friday, May 3, 2013

Victorian Stereotypes of Women and Men are Alive and Well

A recent article in The Atlantic discusses how Republican and Democratic operatives alike are looking hard for women candidates.  This isn't just because the gender gap played such a large role in Democrats' success in the last election.  Researchers find that voters are likely to view women candidates as more trustworthy than male ones, as being more likely to challenge the "boys' club" of insider Washington politics, to represent faithfully the interests of ordinary people back home.

But a sidebar to the same article notes that gender stereotypes usually don't work in women's favor.  People who view resumes that are identical except for the names of the applicants (Heidi versus Howard, for example) are much more likely to rate the male candidate as more qualified, whether the job is as a software engineer, researcher, or violist.  The differences are not small.  One study found that female musicians were 50 percent more likely to audition successfully if listeners did not know their gender, if they only heard the music and did not see it being played.

In other words, we tend to assume that women are nicer but less intelligent and talented than men.

http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2013/05/a-womans-edge/309284

Thursday, April 25, 2013

Why Women Do Better In School and Still Make Less than Men Do

There are of course many answers to the question of why females have been outperforming men all the way through their educational careers, straight through to graduate or law school, then end up making less money.  But I've just learned of a new one.

It's long been clear that men benefit from a variety of sexist traditions at work, including: an over-valuation of occupations dominated by men; assumptions that men are supporting families and therefore should earn more than women; and work cultures that are simply more critical of and hostile to women.  At the top of the occupational ladder, highly educated women are more likely than their male peers to work part time or not at all because they are more likely to want to spend time with their children--and to recognize that their highly ambitious husbands are not likely to cut back much on their 80-hour work weeks to share that responsibility.

But  a recent Atlantic review of Sheryl Sandberg's book, Lean In, passes along some gender differences that I was not aware of, namely that once high-performing women leave college they are, on average, much less assertive than the male counterparts they have just finished pulverising in the classroom.  Men are much more likely to demand raises and to shoot for higher positions.  In sum, male employees tend to be more confident than female ones--though they would seem to have less reason to be.  And this confidence is often rewarded. 

Friday, April 19, 2013

Can Everyone Be a Winner? Reflections on Track and Field

My high school son, Peter, recently started competing in track and field after many years of playing soccer, and, as a former cross country and track guy, it's brought back a lot of pleasant memories.  And it's humbling to realize that after less than four weeks of training and three meets, he's already within 5 seconds of my best 800 meter time, which I achieved after logging about 6,000 miles of running over three years.

But watching track meets has also reminded me of the many strengths of timed and measured competitions.  In soccer, everyone is part of a team that wins, loses, or draws.  No matter how well one plays, the outcome essentially determines whether or not you were successful.  As the players age, they learn that needling your opponent or trying to injure him or her when the referees are not looking is often part of the game.  But the players generally behave with much more civility than their parents do.  Some years ago Oregon's head of refereeing told a group of coaches that he had a simple suggestion for improving the quality of soccer matches: ban the parents.

In track, on the other hand, one can finish last but still celebrate a "PR" (personal record).  There is a team score, but it's hard to keep track of.  The girls and the boys compete separately, but at the same meet, and everyone seems to cheer for everyone--parents and athletes.

Not only does everyone get to play, but politics (how much clout one's parents have) don't much enter into the pecking order.  "Stopwatch don't lie" means that the results clearly show who deserves to be on varsity in a given event.

Best of all, there are no controversies over playing time; the slower you are, the longer you are out there.

Friday, April 12, 2013

Video of Anani Memorial International School


My very talented and generous life partner, Wendy, made this short clip from video and photographs I collected while at this amazing school last September.
http://www.friendsofanani.org/

Friday, April 5, 2013

A Shrinking Professoriate?

Today's New York Times brings more bad news for professors: an automated grading system that evidently does a pretty good job of grading short answers--and does so almost instantaneously rather than taking a week or more.  The hope is that such technology will free faculty up for other duties.  Of course those "other duties" will often entail looking for a new job.  With undergraduate tuition continuing its ever-upward spiral, cutting labor costs is, understandably, a primary goal for administrators.  If technology can deliver outstanding online lectures and reliable assessment tools, then won't we simply need fewer professors?

The article notes that there are many skeptics--but also that most of the skeptics come from elite universities at which undergraduates receive a lot of individual care.  It seems to me that for the rest of us survival depends on providing students with the sort of attention that is too often missing at many universities.  If we believe that we can't be replaced by software programs and canned lectures, the onus is on us (no pun intended) to prove it.  The millions of students confronting murky employment possibilities and massive debts are soon going to be voting with their feet--and mouses.

Link to the story

Friday, March 29, 2013

National Geographic, Somalia, and Rwanda

I noticed a very interesting and troubling trend while continuing my research in National Geographic this week. 

Throughout the late 1980s and early 1990s the magazine was treating Sub-Saharan African more respectfully than it had in the 1970s.  The photographs of black Africans were less exotic.  More black Africans were quoted in the articles and depicted doing modern activities: going to school, working as professionals, protecting national parks.  Even articles on big game and the need to preserve them also mentioned the need to balance the needs of humans and animals, recognized that humans were part of the ecosystem.  There was even a piece by Paul Theroux, the old Peace Corps Volunteer and arch anti-romantic, returning to Malawi to find the populace generally capable and optimistic.

Then the magazine's coverage of African people (as opposed to wildlife) plunged around 1992-93.  This was evidently due to two events.  First, the killing of several American marines in Somalia; second, the genocide in Rwanda.  The magazine had offered a pretty upbeat piece on the arrival of American soldiers in Somalia.  It offered no such treatment of the bloody aftermath.  The bloodshed in Rwanda also took it by surprise.  It published two pieces in the aftermath, both of which focused on the fate of the mountain gorillas made famous by Dian Fossey rather than the stunning loss of human life.  The following month the magazine published a cover article on Jane Goodall, the famous British researcher of African chimpanzees.

I think that these choices and silences speak very loudly to Americans' unease with African tragedies.  The easy way out is to ignore them--or to focus on the continent's charismatic mega-fauna. 

Thursday, March 21, 2013

Western Photography and Black Africa

As part of my research for what I hope will some day be a book entitled something like: Africa Existential: American Quests on the "Dark Continent" I've been slogging my way through back issues of National Geographic.  This means examining scores of photographs of "tribal" scarification, pointy-breasted maidens, and vividly painted warriors.  National Geographic has long been drawn to the exotic, and through the 1970s it was a rare article on Africa that did not feature wildly dressed natives, stunning wildlife, or both.  Black Africans evidently spent most of their time dancing and holding ceremonies.

It was with no small amount of wonder and gratitude, then, that yesterday I ran across a 1979 article written by a woman from Uganda and her white Canadian fiance--the first I have found with a black African author.  She had left Uganda to go to college in North America shortly after Idi Amin came to power, met her future husband, and they determined to live in Uganda and run a medical clinic.  The article's opening photograph features the dark-skinned woman woman smiling comfortably at the camera while kneeling at her aunts' feet.  Of the hundreds of photographs I have viewed of black Africans since 1945 in the magazine's glossy pages, this was the first in which I felt that the subject was being presented as fully human.  It was as if a massive, if unspoken, barrier separating "us" and "them" had been breached.  A later photograph conveyed a similar message.  Here the young woman was wearing a more exotic costume and walking away from the camera with her white husband.  They were holding hands.

I have found two major sources of photographs that dwelt on the humanity rather than the (perceived) peculiarity of black Africans long before 1979: those by black African photographers and those by the black American photographers of Ebony.